Horizontal Line

The entire Rustic Tavern team would like to thank ALL of our patrons for allowing us to serve you for 20 excellent years!
We look forward to at least 20 more!

Starting Monday, April 3rd, we will ONLY be taking Reservations for groups of Eight people or more. Any groups under eight will be provided on a first come, first served basis.

We are open to serve your needs on all take-out orders! Call 717-245-2999 to place your order. Enjoy our voted Best Of crab cakes, steaks, or seafood in the comfort of your home!

New Hours Monday – Saturday 11:00am – 10:00pm

We are open to serve your needs on all take-out orders! Call 717-245-2999 to place your order. Enjoy our voted Best Of crab cakes, steaks, or seafood in the comfort of your home!

New Hours
Monday – Saturday
11:00am – 8:00pm

The Rustic Tavern Menu

Weekly Specials

Monday Night

1.5 Lb Crab Legs With Two Sides for $29.99

Tuesday Night

Steamed Clams $5.95 per dozen

Wednesday Night

2lb. Of our Rustic St. Louis style Ribs……$23.99

Friday & Saturday Night

14 Oz Prime Rib with Two Sides for $29.99

Lunch Menu

Soup

French Onion
5.99

Soup of the Day
4.99

Breaded Rustic Wings

w/ blue cheese & celery
(Hot, Mild, Hot Garlic, Old Bay, BBQ, Spicy BBQ, Sweet Chili)

½ lb – 8.99

1 lb – 13.99

Flat Breads

T’s Flatbread
Chicken, bacon, ranch, tomato, onion, cheese
10.99

Zorba’s
Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta, Shrimp & Provolone
12.99

Salads

Tossed
10.99

Caesar
10.99

Greek
13.99

Add Salmon $5.99 Add Chicken $4.99
Add Shrimp $5.99 Add Portabellos $3.99

City Salad
Tossed House Salad topped with fries, Portabello, Steak & Cheese
15.99

Light Fare

All offered w/ one side dish

Crab Cake
17.99

Haddock
14.99

Stuffed Shrimp
16.99

Fish & Chips
14.99

Sweet Chili Salmon
14.99

8 oz. Filet Mignon
33.99

Fettuccini Alfredo
Served w/ garlic bread
15.99

Baked Spaghetti
Served w/ garlic bread
13.99

Pork Chop
12.99

NY Strip
26.99

½ Rack Ribs
18.99

FRESH GRILLED CHICKEN OR
LOCAL PA PASTURES BEEF

Served on Homemade Roll with Pickles & Chips
Add French Fries $1.99 Add Sweet Fries $1.99 Add Onion Rings $1.99

Deluxe
With choice of Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Mayo and pickles
10.99

Western
Bacon, Cheese, BBQ sauce, Onion Rings
11.99

Rustic
Cheese, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions
12.99

Mediterranean
Tomatoes, Feta & Greek Dressing
11.99

Chesapeake
Crab cake, cheese & Imperial Sauce
15.99

Handhelds

Served with Pickles & Chips​
Add French Fries $1.99 Add Sweet Fries $1.99 Add Onion Rings $1.99

Fish Tacos
2 tacos filled w/ Haddock, lettuce, asian slaw, tomato, onion & chipotle aioli
10.99

Baja Chicken Taco
2 tacos filled w/ chicken, lettuce, cheese, tomato, onion & chipotle aioli
9.99

Buffalo Chicken Caesar Wrap
Chicken, hot sauce, romaine, parmesan cheese and caesar dressing
9.99

T’s Wrap
Stuffed with chicken, bacon, ranch, onions, tomato and cheese
10.99

Chicken Parmesan Wrap
Stuffed with breaded chicken, marinara and provolone
10.99

Steak & Portabello Wrap
Stuffed with steak, portobello mushrooms and provolone
13.99

Rustic Ribeye Sandwich
8oz Ribeye topped with provolone, mushrooms & onions
15.99

The Vegan
Stuffed w/ grilled portobellos, onions, peppers, lettuce and tomato
8.99

Salmon BLT
Fresh salmon, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo
13.99

Salmon Melt
Salmon, tomato, monterey jack and cheddar
11.99

Haddock Sandwich Broiled or Fried
Fresh haddock, lettuce, tomato & a side of tartar
12.99

Crab Cake
Our famous crab cake on roll w/ lettuce, tomato and a side of tartar
16.99

Crab Cake Melt
Crab cake, tomato, monterey jack and cheddar
16.99

Sides

Sweet Potato Fries , French Fries, Onion Rings, Steamed Veggies, Cole Slaw, Caesar Salad, Tossed Salad, Apple Sauce

Beverages

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea, Raspberry Tea, Tonic, Ginger Ale, Root Beer, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt. Dew, Sierra Mist, Club Soda
2.99

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
18% GRATUITY ADDED FOR PARTIES OF 8 OR MORE

Dinner Menu

Appetizers

Soup of the Day
4.99

Baked French Onion
5.99

Tavern Stuffed Mushrooms with Crab Imperial
14.99

T’s Flatbread
Our flatbread topped with chicken, bacon, tomato, onions, ranch and cheese, baked until crisp and delicious
10.99

Zorba’s Flatbread
Our flatbread topped with shrimp, tomatoes, spinach, feta and provolone cheese, then baked crisp and delicious
12.99

[GF] Bacon Wrapped Scallops
14.99

 Saganaki
Imported Flaming Greek Cheese
11.99

Jumbo Breaded Rustic Wings
Sweet Chili, Old Bay, Hot, Mild, BBQ, Hot Garlic with celery and bleu cheese.
(½ lb.) 8.99
(1 lb.) 13.99

[GF] Fresh Steamed Clams
in Garlic Butter
9.99

Breaded Buffalo Scallops
with celery and ​bleu cheese
14.99

Cheesy Garlic Bread
with marinara sauce
9.99

Fish Tacos
Fresh Haddock wrapped in a flour tortilla topped with chipotle aioli, tomato, onion, and Asian slaw
10.99

[GF] ½ lb. Steamed Texas Bay Shrimp
13.99

 

PA PASTURES
FRESHLY CHAR-BROILED

[GF] Located 4.7 miles from the Rustic Tavern
Pennsylvania Pasture’s beef is raised 6 miles West of Carlisle. We believe in a local food system that you can trust. Our Beef is Antibiotic and Growth Hormone free and selectively bred to maximize marbling and tenderness. We are farmer’s, butchers, neighbors, and friends and we have a steak in your future.

8 oz. Filet Mignon
33.99

12 oz. New York Strip
26.99

14 oz. Delmonico
29.99

Rustic Bone In 16oz Ribeye
32.99

St. Louis Pork Ribs
2 lbs. 26.99
1 lbs. 18.99

Center Cut Pork Chops
19.99

ADD ONS

 Go Zorba
Sautéed Shrimp, tomatoes, and spinach in a feta cream sauce
10.99

Add Sautéed Mushrooms and Onions 3.99

Add Bleu Cheese 3.99

Add a Crab Cake 15.99

Add Scallops 13.99

Mixed Grille*

Choose two items with two sides 22.99
Choose three items with two sides 33.99

Rustic Center Cut Pork Chop

1⁄3 Rack of Rustic St. Louis Ribs

Cheese Tortellini and Crab Alfredo

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

Breaded Chicken Parmesan

Sweet Chili Salmon

Breaded Shrimp

Bay Shrimp & Sea Scallop Skewer

Broiled Shrimp Scampi

Fresh Lemon-Pepper Panko Haddock

[VB] Broiled Rustic Crab Cake – Add $3.00

Breaded Scallops – Add $3.00

Broiled Maine Scallops – Add $3.00

Stuffed Shrimp with Imperial Crab – Add $3.00

Salads

All served with our own sun-dried tomato and basil tortilla.
Add salmon or shrimp to any salad 5.99, grilled chicken 4.99

Rustic Tossed
Fresh greens topped with tomatoes, green peppers, cucumbers, and onions​
10.99

Crisp Caesar Salad
Crisp Romaine tossed with Caesar dressing and topped with croutons and grated Romano cheese
10.99

House Greek Salad
Tossed Salad topped with pepperoncini, tomatoes, olives, green peppers, onions, and feta cheese
13.99

City Steak Salad
Our own Rustic Tossed Salad topped with charred steak, potatoes, cheese, onions, ​and portabello mushrooms
15.99

 

FRESH GRILLED CHICKEN OR 
PA PASTURES BURGERS

Served on house roll with pickles or chips
Add french fries, onion rings or sweet potato fries for an extra 1.99

House Deluxe
Choice of Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, and Mayo
10.99

Western
Bacon, Cheese, BBQ Sauce, Onion Rings
11.99

Rustic
Cheese, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions
12.99

Mediterranean
Tomatoes, Feta & Greek Dressing
11.99

Signature Sandwiches

Served with chips, pickles, lettuce and tomato
Add french fries, onion rings or sweet potato fries for an extra 1.99

​Rustic Ribeye Steak Sandwich
Served with Provolone, onion & relish
15.99

[VB] ​Crab Cake Sandwich
“Awarded Best”
16.99

Broiled Lemon Pepper Panko Haddock Sandwich
Served with tartar sauce
12.99

Fresh Seafood

​Includes a choice of two side dishes

​Stuffed Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp stuffed with Crab Imperial
27.99

​Lemon-Pepper Panko Broiled Haddock
Fresh, lightly broiled with butter, panko seasoned
19.99

​[VB] Rustic Crab Cakes
“Award Winning” in-house specialty
28.99

​​Crab Stuffed Haddock
Stuffed and baked in our creamy ​Imperial Sauce
26.99

​Jumbo Breaded Shrimp
Served with cocktail sauce
18.99

[GF] Broiled Fresh Maine Scallops
Fresh Northern Scallops broiled with old bay and lemon pepper butter
28.99

[GF] ​Sweet Chili Salmon
Fresh Northern Salmon seasoned with a sweet chili marinade and broiled to perfection
21.99

RUSTIC PASTA

​Served with salad and garlic bread

Cheese Tortellini and Crab Alfredo
in creamy alfredo sauce
22.99

Rustic Fettuccine Alfredo
Tossed with crab, shrimp, scallops in our house alfredo
24.99

Seafood Marinette
Sauteéd shrimp, scallops, and crab in our house marinara sauce
24.99

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Charred chicken tossed in our house alfredo & fettuccine
18.99

Shrimp and Scallop Zorba
Sautéed tomatoes, spinach, garlic, shrimp, and scallops in our feta cream sauce over fettuccine
24.99

Breaded Chicken Parmesan
Pounded & breaded chicken topped with marinara and provolone. Served over spaghetti
17.99

Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine tossed in our house alfredo
16.99

Sides

Substitute Greek Salad for 3.99
Apple Sauce, Coleslaw, Tossed Salad, Caesar Salad, French Fries, Sweet Potato Fries, Baked Potato, Baked Sweet Potato, Veggie of the Day, Onion Rings.

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
18% GRATUITY ADDED FOR PARTIES OF 8 OR MORE

Rustic Tavern Wine List

White

Dark Horse Chardonnay California
Glass – 8.00 Bottle – 34.00

William Hill Chardonnay California
Glass – 9.00 Bottle – 36.00

Ecco Domani Pinot Grigio Italy
Glass – 8.00 Bottle – 34.00

Relax Riesling Germany
Glass – 8.00 Bottle – 34.00

Santa Ema Sauvignon Blanc Chile
Glass – 8.00 Bottle – 34.00

Barefoot Moscato California
Glass – 9.00

Red

Kenwood Yulupa Cabernet California
Glass – 9.00 Bottle – 36.00

Dark Horse Cabernet California
Glass – 9.00 Bottle – 36.00

Mirassou Pinot Noir California
Glass – 9.00 Bottle – 36.00

Alamos Malbec Argentina
Glass – 9.00 Bottle – 36.00

Apothic Winemaker’s Blend
(Zinfandel, Merlot, Cab, Syrah)
Glass – 9.00 Bottle – 36.00

House

Chardonnay, Cabernet, Merlot & White Zinfandel
Provided by Woodbridge by Robert Mondaui
Glass – 7.00

Beverages

Specialty Coffees

8.50 each

Rustic Cafe
Frangelico, Buttershots, Coffee Topped w/ Whipped Cream

Irish Coffee
Tullamore D.E.W., Creme de Menthe, Coffee Topped w/ Whipped Cream

Mexican Coffee
Kahlua and Coffee Topped w/Whipped Cream

Bailey’s Coffee
Baily’s Irish Cream and Coffee Topped w/ Whipped Cream

Signature Cocktails

Orange Crush
Stoli Ohranj, Triple Sec, Fresh Squeezed OJ, Sierra Mist
7.50

Grapefruit Crush
Tito’s Vodka, Triple Sec, Fresh Squeezed Grapefruit, Sierra Mist
7.50

Stoli Mule
Stoli Vodka (your choice of flavor), Ginger Beer, and Lime Juice in a copper mug
8.00

Irish Fashioned
Tullamore D.E.W., Bitters, Sugar, Muddled Orange & Cherry
9.00

Coco Rita
1800 Coconut Tequila, Triple Sec, Sours, Lime
10.00

Triple Berry Lemonade
Three Olives Berry Vodka, Mr. Boston Black Raspberry Liqueur, Lemonade
8.00

Featured Martinis

12.00 each

​Flavored Cosmopolitans
Choices of Cherry, Raspberry, Mango, Blueberry Vodka, Triple Sec, Lime, Cranberry

​Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Whipped Vodka, DiSaronno, Pineapple Juice

​Washington Apple
Crown Royal, Sour Apple Schnapps, Cranberry Juice

Snickers
Stoli Vanil, Frangelico, Light and Dark Creme de Cacao, Buttershots & Cream

​Orange & Cream
Stoli Ohranj, Stoli Vanilla, White Creme de Cacao, Splash of orange juice

​Red Velvet Martini
Whipped Vodka, Chambord, Cranberry & Pineapple Juice