Now Open for Lunch and Dinner!

COVID-19 Update: Indoor seating is limited to 25% capacity per PA Health Dept. Take-out orders are welcome! Heated enclosed patio seating is available!

Call 717-245-2999 to place your order or to check seating availability.

Open Monday – Saturday 11:00am – 10:00pm

Voted best crab cakes & seafood!
Voted best steaks!

Welcome to The Rustic Tavern

Voted the Best in Cumberland County Since 2008

Tom, Penny, and the family would like to extend our warmest welcome to everyone visiting our brand new website. We have had the pleasure of serving the Carlisle area for 18 years! We offer a wide range of choices from the casual meal to the fine dining experience. Our daily specials constantly change with the season and the creativity of our chef.

Thank you again for 18 wonderful years of your patronage!

-The Petsinis Family

Alcohol Specials

Take out orders of your favorite mixed drinks and beer are available!

$5 Orange Crush – Daily Special

$5 Grapefruit Crush – Daily Special

*Must be 21 to purchase. ID will be required for all alcohol take out orders.